Wholesome Ingredients Straight to Your Dinner Table

Explore our pickle, olive and mushroom products

Everything's Pickled to Perfection

Shop for delicious pickled products

All pickles are not made equal. If you want optimal flavor and sealed-in freshness, you want Gary's Pickles. Our business was founded in 1986 in New Paltz, NY. More than 30 years later, we keep the tradition of exceptional pickles and other products alive.

You can find our pickles at the Indoor Flea Market or order from our warehouse. Can't visit us in person? Ask us if you're favorites are available to ship.

Great quality from our family to yours

Our family-owned and -operated pickle business is focused on quality and customer satisfaction. We believe in wholesome, well-made food. That's why we've taken the time to develop a trusted recipe and pickling process. You don't have to worry about chemicals and harmful ingredients in our products.

Don't just take our word for it - try pickles or other products for yourself today.

Browse our product options

What are you hungry for? We've cultivated recipes for multiple pickle flavors. Plus, we pickle all kinds of food to create iconic snacks and sides. Our tasty products include:

  • Full sour pickles
  • Half sour pickles
  • Hot and spicy pickles
  • Pickled tomatoes
  • Sauerkraut
  • Bread and butter chips
  • Marinated mushrooms
  • Sweet gherkin pickles
  • Sweet horseradish chips
  • Red Cerignola olives
  • Stuffed olives


Everything is kosher except our olives. Our products are perfect sandwich ingredients, snacks and charcuterie board accouterments. Call 845-591-9435 now to learn more about our business.

Meet the Owner:

Barry Bliden